Evanson attended Nostalgi-Con, where he had a booth for Keagan's Pond. Marge and Lisa made plans to meet him at the convention, but Lisa never showed up so Marge went alone. Nobody else attended the meetup, so Marge spent the entire time talking with Evanson while waiting for Lisa. Evanson spoke about his lawsuit against the makers of the Keagan's Pond slot machine, showed off his scar, did some one-handed pushups, cried in Marge's arms, and shared a tub of pasta with Marge. Evanson then had to leave before the convention organizers charged him for a full-day table rental. He then invited Marge to "do it" in the men's shelter he was staying at.
Later, Marge said that meeting Keagan was "unsettling."
