In the 1930s, Abraham Simpson was the Able-Bodied Boy, a sidekick-for-hire in Springfield. He and other sidekicks would wait on street corners for superheroes to pick them up to do missions. One day, no superhero picked the Able-Bodied Boy, and he was left alone. The Mystery Gunman then arrived to pick him up, but upon learning he would get paid in commission only, the Able-Bodied Boy refused to work with him. The Able-Bodied Boy went to The Diamond Club, where the Puzzling Purloiner was supposed to strike. The Able-Bodied Boy started a fight with Kid Dirigible, which resulted in a fire on Kid Dirigible's boss, The Mighty Zeppelin. During the chaos, the Puzzling Purloiner stole the world's largest diamond.
In the present day, Grampa found out that Bart was Bartman. He agreed to do one last job with Bart before he hung up his cape for good because Grampa said that being a superhero was too dangerous. Grampa put on his old costume and helped take down Hans Moleman, who was behind all the crimes involving riddles.