Difference between revisions of "Wikisimpsons:Comprehensive article nominations/Archive 3"

Revision as of 03:36, August 1, 2016

Passed

SpringShield

A good small article. /AleWi (talk) 12:36, September 29, 2014 (EDT)

Support (4)

1. Looks Good. / Loco87 ^{(TALK / Contribs)} 15:41, September 30, 2014 (EDT)
2. I agree. --Nick97 ^{(talk ~ contribs)} 00:26, October 1, 2014 (EDT)
3. --Fred (Talk • Contribs. • Editcount) 08:37, October 1, 2014 (EDT)
4. A good short article. -- Mythigator (talk) 09:24, October 1, 2014 (EDT)

Neutral (0)

Oppose (0)

Comments

Elijah Hooper

Great article Solar created. Very detailed. --Fred (Talk • Contribs.) 03:47, November 7, 2014 (EST)

Support (1)

1. We need a Comprehensive article for next month and this looks good for that. / Loco87 ^{(TALK / Contribs)} 10:21, January 31, 2015 (EST)

Neutral (0)

Oppose (0)

Comments

Leonard Nimoy

It may fit as comprehensive article. And it will also be a great tribute to the late Leonard Nimoy, / Loco87 ^{(TALK / Contribs)} 15:10, February 27, 2015 (EST)

Support (5)

1. —Preceding unsigned comment added by Bleedinggumsmurphy1 (talk • contribs) 16:17, February 27, 2015 (EST)
2. It'll be nice for March and a tribute to a true legend. —Fred (Talk • Contribs.) 05:22, February 28, 2015 (EST)
3. -- Webkinz ManiaTalkContributionsEditcount 10:53, February 28, 2015 (EST)
4. Made a couple of changes to the article including fleshing out a bit of his monorail appearance and adding a quote. Now, I agree. The Solar Dragon 10:56, February 28, 2015 (EST)
5. I think the comic bit could be moved out of non-canon, since the comic story itself is canon from the looks of it. Other than that looks good! --Nick97 ^{(talk ~ contribs)} 12:09, February 28, 2015 (EST)

Neutral (0)

Oppose (0)

Comments

Wonderbat

It may fit as comprehensive article. / Loco87 ^{(TALK / Contribs)} 15:10, February 27, 2015 (EST)

Support (1)

1. Yep, that works well. The Solar Dragon 13:38, February 28, 2015 (EST)

Neutral (0)

Oppose (0)

Comments

The Pooter Toot Express

It may fit as comprehensive article. / Loco87 ^{(TALK / Contribs)} 15:10, February 27, 2015 (EST)

Support (1)

1. All good now. The Solar Dragon 14:27, February 28, 2015 (EST)

Neutral (0)

#I would like to see the images improved before we pass it. Otherwise, it's fine. The Solar Dragon 13:38, February 28, 2015 (EST)

Oppose (0)

Comments

• I've replaced the images with better quality versions. / Loco87 ^{(TALK / Contribs)} 14:22, February 28, 2015 (EST)

Larry the Lamb

It may fit as comprehensive article. / Loco87 ^{(TALK / Contribs)} 15:10, February 27, 2015 (EST)

Support (4)

1. *thumbs up* The Solar Dragon 13:38, February 28, 2015 (EST)
2. —Fred (Talk • Contribs.) 07:17, May 1, 2015 (EDT)
3. Agree T-Mac (talk) 18:29, May 4, 2015 (EDT)
4. Personally was more feeling the carbon rod, but I didn't want to create a tie haha. This article still looks good though. --Nick97 ^{(talk ~ contribs)} 01:18, May 31, 2015 (EDT)

Neutral (0)

Oppose (0)

Comments

Inanimate carbon rod

It may fit as comprehensive article. / Loco87 ^{(TALK / Contribs)} 15:10, February 27, 2015 (EST)

Support (3)

1. Okay, this one works. The Solar Dragon 13:38, February 28, 2015 (EST)
2. —Fred (Talk • Contribs.) 07:17, May 1, 2015 (EDT)
3. Best character. --Nick97 ^{(talk ~ contribs)} 21:29, June 27, 2015 (EDT)

Neutral (0)

Oppose (0)

Comments

Ted Nugent

It may fit as comprehensive article. / Loco87 ^{(TALK / Contribs)} 15:10, February 27, 2015 (EST)

Support (3)

1. Okay, this works. The Solar Dragon 13:38, February 28, 2015 (EST)
2. —Fred (Talk • Contribs.) 07:17, May 1, 2015 (EDT)
3. Mythi likey! -- Mythigator (talk) 01:05, July 30, 2015 (EDT)

Neutral (0)

Oppose (0)

Comments

Male Golem

It may fit as comprehensive article for October. / Loco87 ^{(TALK / Contribs)} 10:20, September 30, 2015 (EDT)

Support (0)

Neutral (0)

Oppose (0)

Comments

• We needed a Comprehensive article for October. / Loco87 ^{( / Contribs)} 10:26, October 1, 2015 (EDT)

Lucille Botzcowski

A good one. / Loco87 ^{( / Contribs)} 06:17, November 1, 2015 (EST)

Support (0)

Neutral (0)

Oppose (0)

Comments

• A comprehensive article for November was needed. / Loco87 ^{( / Contribs)} 06:17, November 1, 2015 (EST)

The Christmas That Almost Wasn't But Then Was

It may fit as a Christmas-themed Comprehensive article. / Loco87 ^{( / Contribs)} 10:04, November 29, 2015 (EST)

Support (1)

I feel like it could use an image or two of the actual movie (not just the title screen), but other than that it looks good. --Nick97 ^{(talk ~ contribs)} 12:00, November 30, 2015 (EST)

Neutral (0)

Oppose (0)

Comments

Kentucky Fried Panda

A good article. / Loco87 ^{(TALK / Contribs)} 07:47, January 2, 2016 (EST)

Support (0)

Neutral (0)

Oppose (0)

Comments

• A comprehensive article for January was needed. / Loco87 ^{(TALK / Contribs)} 07:47, January 2, 2016 (EST)

Olmec head

It may fit as comprehensive article. / Loco87 ^{(TALK / Contribs)} 15:10, February 27, 2015 (EST)

Support (1)

1. Seems good to me now. The Solar Dragon 16:36, January 7, 2016 (EST)

Neutral (0)

Oppose (0)

#The first part is just a block of text. No sections. "In the comics" is written in the next, not in-universe. The Solar Dragon 13:38, February 28, 2015 (EST)

Comments

Paula Paul

Complete article, too short for featured. The Solar Dragon 16:35, January 7, 2016 (EST)

Support (1)

1. Complete article and I've uploaded a better quality version of its picture. / Loco87 ^{(TALK / Contribs)} 06:34, January 8, 2016 (EST)

Neutral (0)

Oppose (0)

Comments

The Singing Sirloin

Not long enough to be a featured article but long enough to be comprehensive. / Loco87 ^{(TALK / Contribs)} 12:36, March 22, 2016 (EDT)

Support (0)

Neutral (0)

Oppose (0)

Comments

• A comprehensive article for April was needed. / Loco87 ^{(TALK / Contribs)} 07:32, April 1, 2016 (EDT)

E.A.R.L.

Not long enough to be a featured article but long enough to be comprehensive. / Loco87 ^{(Talk / Contribs)} 06:50, May 1, 2016 (EDT)

Support (0)

Neutral (0)

Oppose (0)

Comments

• A comprehensive article for May was needed. / Loco87 ^{(Talk / Contribs)} 06:50, May 1, 2016 (EDT)

Itchy & Scratchy robots

A comprehensive article for June. / Loco87 ^{(TALK / Contribs)} 15:37, June 1, 2016 (EDT)

Support (0)

Neutral (0)

Oppose (0)

Comments

• A comprehensive article for June was needed. / Loco87 ^{(TALK / Contribs)} 15:37, June 1, 2016 (EDT)

Fan Man

Seems like a complete and fleshed out article for a minor character. The Solar Dragon 09:23, June 30, 2016 (EDT)

Support (2)

1. Concur. I remember working on this one; I'd forgotten that it actually turned out to be pretty good. -- Mythigator (talk) 12:09, June 30, 2016 (EDT)
2. Great article. / Loco87 ^{(TALK / Contribs)} 08:17, July 1, 2016 (EDT)

Neutral (0)

Oppose (0)

Comments

Man Getting Hit by Football

Complete article, definitely not long enough for featured. The Solar Dragon 06:25, July 5, 2016 (EDT)

Support (2)

1. Great article (and short film). / Loco87 ^{(TALK / Contribs)} 10:02, July 31, 2016 (EDT)
2. Football in the groin! Football in the groin! -- Mythigator (talk) 18:42, July 31, 2016 (EDT)

Neutral (0)

Oppose (0)

Comments

Rejected

Burns portrait

It may fit as comprehensive article. / Loco87 ^{(TALK / Contribs)} 15:10, February 27, 2015 (EST)

Support (0)

Neutral (0)

Oppose (2)

1. Would like to see a better quality image first. Also, I feel more could be said about it. Why Burns asked Marge to paint it etc. The Solar Dragon 13:38, February 28, 2015 (EST)
2. Concur with Solar. This is a good example of the type of article that should get Comprehensive status, but it needs some work. -- Mythigator (talk) 01:06, July 30, 2015 (EDT)

Comments

Withdrawn

Gypsy

It may fit as comprehensive article for October. / Loco87 ^{(TALK / Contribs)} 10:20, September 30, 2015 (EDT)

Support (0)

Neutral (0)

Oppose (1)

1. I believe this is good enough to stretch to featured. The Solar Dragon 16:37, January 7, 2016 (EST)

Comments

• Needs an MoS makeover. -- Mythigator (talk) 16:57, March 31, 2016 (EDT)
  • I've withdrawn it because Solar is right it is good enough to be a featured article. So, I'll nominate it for featured in September, so it may be featured in October. / Loco87 ^{(TALK / Contribs)} 07:32, April 1, 2016 (EDT)