Difference between revisions of "Wikisimpsons:Pages for deletion"
Wikisimpsons - The Simpsons Wiki
Solar Dragon (talk | contribs) |
Solar Dragon (talk | contribs) m |
||
| (16 intermediate revisions by 4 users not shown) | |||
| Line 15: | Line 15: | ||
== Nominations == | == Nominations == | ||
| + | === [[The Monster]], [[Dr._Itchystein]] and [[Mrs. Itchystein]] === | ||
| + | [[The Monster]] and [[Dr. Itchystein]] are just [[Scratchy]] and [[Itchy]] portraying the characters from Frankenstein without any real notable differences. [[Mrs. Itchystein]] is arguably just [[Mrs. Scratchy]] portraying the Bride of Frankenstein and doesn't even have a name; the article title is conjectural. At most, I could see [[Frankenscratchy]] and [[Mad Doctor Itchy]] from the show getting a page, as they were in ''[[The Simpsons: Tapped Out]]'', with the info of their comic counterparts being present on their pages. [[User:Sideshow Raheem|Sideshow Raheem]] ([[User talk:Sideshow Raheem|talk]]) 21:09, January 9, 2025 (EST) | ||
| + | :Disagree. I feel that they're different enough from the original characters to have their own pages. As for merging with Frankenscratchy and Mad Doctor Itchy, the characters are different. However, you are right about the Mrs. Itchystein page title, and it should be changed to "Bride of Itchystein". <span style="font-family:Algerian">[[User:Solar Dragon|<span style="color:green">The</span>]] [[User talk:Solar Dragon|<span style="color:red">Solar</span>]] [[Special:Contributions/Solar Dragon|<span style="color:blue">Dragon</span>]]</span> 06:49, January 10, 2025 (EST) | ||
| + | :: How are they different from their regular counterparts; [[The Monster]] Scratchy is a trusting and friendly fellow that is prone to being murdered just like [[Scratchy]], [[Dr. Itchystein]] is a sadistic lunatic that murders characters for no reason just like [[Itchy]]. The bride connection to [[Mrs. Scratchy]] is looser, but she's still a female love interest for Scratchy. [[Lisa Simpson]] also refers to the episode with them as an [[Itchy]] and [[Scratchy]] cartoon when describing the episode, further implying that they're just Itchy and Scratchy playing a role. Also checking it again, Mrs. Itchystein is referred to as ''the monster's bride'' by Lisa. Also unlike [[Frankenscratchy]] and [[Mad Doctor Itchy]], the two also don't appear in ''Tapped out''. If we're going to have a page for [[Itchy]] and [[Scratchy]]'s Frankenstein inspired alter egos, I think the ones that appeared in ''Tapped Out'' and had unique dialogue with their regular counterparts would be more important to have a page on. [[User:Sideshow Raheem|Sideshow Raheem]] ([[User talk:Sideshow Raheem|talk]]) 16:48, January 10, 2025 (EST) | ||
| + | :::We have articles for variations of other characters, for example characters that appear in THOH episodes. [[Count Burns]], {{Ch|King Homer}} etc. So these characters having their own articles is completely fine. <span style="font-family:Algerian">[[User:Solar Dragon|<span style="color:green">The</span>]] [[User talk:Solar Dragon|<span style="color:red">Solar</span>]] [[Special:Contributions/Solar Dragon|<span style="color:blue">Dragon</span>]]</span> 17:04, January 10, 2025 (EST) | ||
| + | :::: Those THOH characters have enough info to fill up an article, I don't think the Frankenstein Itchy and Scratchy comic characters have enough. And if we give them pages, why should [[Frankenscratchy]] and [[Mad Doctor Itchy]] not be separate pages from [[Scratchy]] and [[Itchy]] given there is more on them, especially with ''Tapped out'' expanding them? [[User:Sideshow Raheem|Sideshow Raheem]] ([[User talk:Sideshow Raheem|talk]]) 14:33, January 11, 2025 (EST) | ||
| + | :::::Whether Frankenscratchy and Mad Dr. Itchy get an article or not is unrelated to this. These are variations of Itchy, Scratchy, and Mrs. Scratchy, and so should have articles based on the [[Wikisimpsons:Notability policy|notability policy]]. They all have names, even if Mrs. Itchystein's page should be moved. Therefore, they fall in line with the notability policy. <span style="font-family:Algerian">[[User:Solar Dragon|<span style="color:green">The</span>]] [[User talk:Solar Dragon|<span style="color:red">Solar</span>]] [[Special:Contributions/Solar Dragon|<span style="color:blue">Dragon</span>]]</span> 14:45, January 11, 2025 (EST) | ||
== See also == | == See also == | ||
Latest revision as of 18:53, January 12, 2025
 |
Pages for deletion (PfD) is where editors discuss whether a page should be deleted. Articles listed are normally discussed for at least five days after which the deletion process proceeds based on community consensus. Then the page may be kept, merged or redirected, moved to another title or deleted.
Creating an PfD discussion[edit]
If you want to create a deletion discussion simply list in the nominations section:
Example Page[edit]
Reason for Deletion ~~~~
Also do not forget to mark the page to be deleted with {{Delete}} on the top.
Nominations[edit]
The Monster, Dr._Itchystein and Mrs. Itchystein[edit]
The Monster and Dr. Itchystein are just Scratchy and Itchy portraying the characters from Frankenstein without any real notable differences. Mrs. Itchystein is arguably just Mrs. Scratchy portraying the Bride of Frankenstein and doesn't even have a name; the article title is conjectural. At most, I could see Frankenscratchy and Mad Doctor Itchy from the show getting a page, as they were in The Simpsons: Tapped Out, with the info of their comic counterparts being present on their pages. Sideshow Raheem (talk) 21:09, January 9, 2025 (EST)
- Disagree. I feel that they're different enough from the original characters to have their own pages. As for merging with Frankenscratchy and Mad Doctor Itchy, the characters are different. However, you are right about the Mrs. Itchystein page title, and it should be changed to "Bride of Itchystein". The Solar Dragon 06:49, January 10, 2025 (EST)
- How are they different from their regular counterparts; The Monster Scratchy is a trusting and friendly fellow that is prone to being murdered just like Scratchy, Dr. Itchystein is a sadistic lunatic that murders characters for no reason just like Itchy. The bride connection to Mrs. Scratchy is looser, but she's still a female love interest for Scratchy. Lisa Simpson also refers to the episode with them as an Itchy and Scratchy cartoon when describing the episode, further implying that they're just Itchy and Scratchy playing a role. Also checking it again, Mrs. Itchystein is referred to as the monster's bride by Lisa. Also unlike Frankenscratchy and Mad Doctor Itchy, the two also don't appear in Tapped out. If we're going to have a page for Itchy and Scratchy's Frankenstein inspired alter egos, I think the ones that appeared in Tapped Out and had unique dialogue with their regular counterparts would be more important to have a page on. Sideshow Raheem (talk) 16:48, January 10, 2025 (EST)
- We have articles for variations of other characters, for example characters that appear in THOH episodes. Count Burns, King Homer etc. So these characters having their own articles is completely fine. The Solar Dragon 17:04, January 10, 2025 (EST)
- Those THOH characters have enough info to fill up an article, I don't think the Frankenstein Itchy and Scratchy comic characters have enough. And if we give them pages, why should Frankenscratchy and Mad Doctor Itchy not be separate pages from Scratchy and Itchy given there is more on them, especially with Tapped out expanding them? Sideshow Raheem (talk) 14:33, January 11, 2025 (EST)
- Whether Frankenscratchy and Mad Dr. Itchy get an article or not is unrelated to this. These are variations of Itchy, Scratchy, and Mrs. Scratchy, and so should have articles based on the notability policy. They all have names, even if Mrs. Itchystein's page should be moved. Therefore, they fall in line with the notability policy. The Solar Dragon 14:45, January 11, 2025 (EST)
- Those THOH characters have enough info to fill up an article, I don't think the Frankenstein Itchy and Scratchy comic characters have enough. And if we give them pages, why should Frankenscratchy and Mad Doctor Itchy not be separate pages from Scratchy and Itchy given there is more on them, especially with Tapped out expanding them? Sideshow Raheem (talk) 14:33, January 11, 2025 (EST)
- We have articles for variations of other characters, for example characters that appear in THOH episodes. Count Burns, King Homer etc. So these characters having their own articles is completely fine. The Solar Dragon 17:04, January 10, 2025 (EST)
- How are they different from their regular counterparts; The Monster Scratchy is a trusting and friendly fellow that is prone to being murdered just like Scratchy, Dr. Itchystein is a sadistic lunatic that murders characters for no reason just like Itchy. The bride connection to Mrs. Scratchy is looser, but she's still a female love interest for Scratchy. Lisa Simpson also refers to the episode with them as an Itchy and Scratchy cartoon when describing the episode, further implying that they're just Itchy and Scratchy playing a role. Also checking it again, Mrs. Itchystein is referred to as the monster's bride by Lisa. Also unlike Frankenscratchy and Mad Doctor Itchy, the two also don't appear in Tapped out. If we're going to have a page for Itchy and Scratchy's Frankenstein inspired alter egos, I think the ones that appeared in Tapped Out and had unique dialogue with their regular counterparts would be more important to have a page on. Sideshow Raheem (talk) 16:48, January 10, 2025 (EST)
